B*tches betta come together. Narratives of sisterhood in pop music videos
Recently the use of the word feminist has become fashionable for female pop musicians. Among them was Beyoncé, who made a statement during her 2014 MTV VMA’s performance by broadcasting the word ‘feminist’ to millions of viewers, whereby it became a worldwide trending topic. Beyonce’s words were part of ongoing revolution of feminism by a growing number of female pop musicians today.
What these musicians have in common is their relationship to their fans through ‘sisterhood’, whether it is in Beyonce’s beyhive, as a little monster or as one of the swifties. The concept of sisterhood, used in music video’s, is becoming a popular way of organizing fan cultures. This new movement in the pop industry will be the main subject in this blogpost. There will be an exploration of representations of femininity in recent music videos by three of today's leading female pop musicians: Taylor Swift, Lady Gaga and Rihanna. Their video clips will be analysed to see how ‘sisterhood’ is constructed and how this is used to either challenge or support patriarchal structures in society. Thereby this blogpost is based on Robin James’ findings in her recent book ‘Resilience and Melancholy’.
Before we go to the music videos, let us start by introducing the term patriarchy. Patriarchy is the system of social organization on the basis of gender. The dominance of men is part of a series of interlocking structures of dominance, expressed by the acronym MRWaSP (Multi-Racial White Supremacist Capitalist Patriarchy). In MRWaSP society, men are on top. Therefore we can say that in a social system where men are on top, the gathering of human capital happens through ‘pleasing the man’; i.e. by gaining patriarchal approval.[1]
Popular culture is of importance in convincing viewers of the self-evident and legitimate nature of MRWaSP. As part a marxist tradition of cultural studies, pop culture and the media are seen as a way of affirming and protecting this hegemonic position of those in power. So, there is an interrelationship between the discursive content of popular culture and the social structures it must justify. In popular culture the performance of gender roles must confirm the social structures wherein women dominated. Therefore the performance of femininity was traditionally based on fragility.[2]
But today’s society is changing, so the performance of femininity in popular music is as well. One of society’s most evident changes is the shift towards a neoliberal political system, which is making the individual responsible for society’s ills. This political system is based on the integration of market values in other domains of society, and the reconsideration of interventional state policy. Because of the ongoing processes of deregulation, the emphasis has shifted towards individual responsibility to protect itself against the exigencies of the market. The translation of these developments in popular culture has led to a narrative of individual accountability and personal development.[3]
In neoliberal society, gender is performed in popular culture by either playing into gender expectations or by actively subverting them. One way of confirming neoliberal patriarchy, is by what James calls the ‘Look, I Overcame’ narrative.[4] In this narrative a women needs patriarchal damage in order to truly become a woman. The narrative is based on the pain inflicted by patriarchy being sublimated into something with a surplus value. As argued by Robin James, in neoliberalism the feminine gender is placed in a therapeutic narrative of female self-empowerment and ‘resilience’ [5]. The music video is part of the performance of turning damage into a visual triumph.
This month Lady Gaga relased her new singel Till it happens to you. The music video deals with sexual assault and its aftermath, and is part of the soundtrack for the upcoming documentary on sexual abuse in American colleges The Hunting Ground. The ‘Till it happens to you’ is part of Gaga’s performance of both feminine damage and the recovery through sisterhood.
The rather graphic depiction of sexual abuse and the message of ‘Till it happens to you’ (as some impending doom awaiting all women), is part of the construction of the ‘resilience’ narrative. In the ‘Till it happens to you’ video, this is transformed into a therapeutic narrative of sisterhood when in the end all women come together in a nurturing embrace of their victimized friends. In gaga’s work sexual abuse is a central topic. In both the videos of Bad Romance and Marry the night she refers to the damage done to her by men. Specifically, in the ‘Marry the Night’ video Gaga is wheeled into a hospital after being sexually assaulted and is told not to have intercourse for period of time. She recovers by becoming a celebrity, not only winning patriarchal approval but establishing herself within that social order. Neoliberalism creates the feeling that patriarchy is history, and moreover that patriarchal violence to women is of value because of the narrative of overcoming.[6] Thereby Gaga’s videos are feeding into narratives of white supremacist capitalist patriarchy, of which she has become a part.
A different approach to the construction of overcoming feminine fragility through sisterhood, is given by Taylor Swift in her Bad blood video. The video starts of with two women played by Taylor Swift and Selena Gomez robbing men in suits in a corporate skyscraper (i.e. patriarchy). But when the fight is over their bond is broken when they turn on eachother. Selena eventually pushes Taylor out of the window, whereafter she takes the entirety of the loot. Taylor proves herself resilient by forming a rather elaborate group of famous girlfriends with whom she fights back.
The ‘Bad Blood’ video shows two women trying to climb the ladders of patriarchy. But when women do, they eventually end up becoming part of this system of dominance and thereby having to compete each other for patriarchal approval. Swift overcomes this problem by creating a sisterhood of friends. James argued that in recent decades there was the emergence of fan cultures as women centric enviromenments. Fan cultures thereby have the potential to form alternative milieus for gathering human capital. So, pop music and fan cultures have become a space for women to establish relations among themselves, and thereby challenging patriarchy.
But these alternative milieus formed in fan cultures can still work with patriarchy, instead of working against it. This is for instance the case with the ‘resilience’ narrative, which values feminine damage. Swift is no stranger to showing her damage; almost all of her former video’s are based on the drama concerning her love interests. However with ‘Bad Blood’, she becomes (finally) resilient. The resilience Swift performs is part of the narrative that women have to partake in in order to become valued as women. What the ‘Bad blood’ is telling women is: you’re either in (by performing feminine damage and heroically recovering from it), or you’re out. The resilience narrative therefore excludes women who do not keep to these rather strict new codes of womanhood. Thereby Swift is scapegoating the women who do not participate in this narrative of feminine overcoming.
A very distinct way of performing femininity is done by Rihanna, who continually positions herself as the odd one out. At first glance her music video Bitch better have my money seems like the ultimate feminist revenge fantasy, but in fact it is not. The video is based on Rihanna and two friends kidnapping another woman, in order for her husband to pay the ransom. But along the way a sisterhood is formed, though this bond isn’t based in shared feminine damage. The women befriend each other, drinking and smoking, having a good time with the prospect of a large amount of cash coming their way because of the extortion. But the man refuses to pay, not finding his spouse worth the money. The women eventually fight patriarchy, by ruthlessly killing ‘the man’.
Rihanna’s construction of sisterhood steers away the central trope of feminine damage: her damage is absent; therefore it can not be turned into a something having surplus value. Another example of this is her not capitalizing on her being assaulted by former boyfriend Chris Brown. Therefore it is not revenge Rihanna is after, it is money. The difference is, Rihanna has no interest in conforming to conventional roles in society. Rihanna distances herself from tidy narratives of femininity, and moves against respectable femininity by broadcasting her shortcomings. Rihanna becomes the ‘other’, a peripheral figure, a criminal even. In doing so she creates a form of human capital on her own terms. Thereby instead of presenting herself as a resilient women, Rihanna is rather performing a pathological form of masculinity.[7]
So, B*tch might’ve gotten her money but still the video ends rather unhappily with Rihanna staring silently into the camera with her face dripping in blood. Rihanna doesn’t overcome, but what the video does is exemplify the sexist (and racist) structures of patriarchy. The BBHMM narrative is based on a divergent narrative of what James calls melancholy – of subverting the story into something disturbing and displacing.[8] Rihanna doesn’t read into social normativity, by showing a woman that refuses to perform or capitalize on damage – there’s no damage done and no sign of personal improvement. Instead, she knows what she wants and is not afraid to get it. Rihanna therefore can’t help but challenge patriarchy and ends up a murderer in the BBHMM video.
These three female voices in pop music show different ways of using feminism and sisterhood. Supporting patriarchy is done by the performance of feminine ‘resilience’, as do Lady Gaga and Taylor Swift. The damaging done by patriarchy of being sexualized and objectified, becomes a position of strength. While they claim that patriarchy is over, it in fact is not. In contrast, Rihanna shows the potential of pop music to address these structures of dominance. Female empowerment through sisterhood and the appropriation of the term feminist can therefore can either confirm or challenge patriarchy.
Tweet: Will the true feminist please stand up? Challenging neoliberal white girlishness may involve killing ‘the man’. #BBHMM#BBHMMmusicvideo
Initials:
A.D.
E.T.
J.M.D.O.M.
M.v.d.V
M.v.R
Notes:
[1] James, http://www.its-her-factory.com/2015/04/rihconomics/ (April 2015) Accessed on: 28 september 2015.
[2] James, Resilience and Melancholy. Pop Music, Feminism and Neoliberalism (Zero Books 2015), p. 81.
[3] Neocleous, M., http://www.radicalphilosophy.com/commentary/resisting-resilience (3-2013) accessed on: 28 september 2015; James, Resilience and Melancholy, p. 97.
[4] James, Resilience and Melancholy, p. 88.
[5] ibidem.
[6] ibidem, 89.
[7] James, http://www.its-her-factory.com/2015/04/rihconomics/ (april 2015) accessed on: 28 september 2015; Felix, Doreen st., 'The Prosperity Gospel of Rihanna' (april 1 2015) accessed on: 28 september 2015.
[8] James, Resilience and Melancholy.
Bibliography:
Felix, Doreen st., 'The Prosperity Gospel of Rihanna' (april 1 2015) accessed on: 28 september 2015.
Neocleous (2013), http://www.radicalphilosophy.com/commentary/resisting-resilience (3-2013) accessed on: 28 september 2015.
James, R., Resilience and Melancholy. Pop Music, Feminism and Neoliberalism (Zero Books 2015).
James, R. (2015) http://www.its-her-factory.com/2015/04/rihconomics/ (april 2015) accessed on: 28 september 2015.
James, R. (2013) http://www.its-her-factory.com/2013/11/notes-on-a-theory-of-multi-racial-white-supremacist-patriarchy-aka-mrwasp/ (11-9-2013) accessed on: 28 september 2015.